General dentistry

Cavity under a filling: signs, why it happens and how it is treated

Dr. Cleo Salustiano
12 Nov 2026 · 6 min read
Updated 12 Nov 2026
Cover of the article 'Cavity under a filling: signs, why it happens and how it is treated', beige background with olive-green title, from Dr. Cleo Salustiano's dental office in Mooca, São Paulo.
Summary
Quick summary of this article+

Decay under a filling, or secondary caries, forms at the margin of a worn, cracked or poorly adapted filling and spreads unseen. Signs include a dark margin, sensitivity, food trapping and a chipped filling, but there may be no symptoms. Exams and X-rays diagnose it. Treatment removes decay and repairs or redoes the filling. Old fillings without problems do not need replacing.

A cavity under a filling, called secondary or recurrent caries, is new decay that forms at the edge of an existing filling and spreads beneath it. It happens when the junction between tooth and filling wears, cracks or develops a ledge, letting plaque in. Because it is hidden, it often grows unseen and is found only when the filling breaks, the tooth darkens or pain appears.

In clinical practice, patients who had a filling years ago often arrive with sensitivity to sweets, food getting stuck or a dark line around the filling. The opposite question is also common: replacing all old fillings with tooth-colored ones even without decay. Not every old filling needs replacing.

In this article, Dr. Cleo Salustiano (CRO-SP 170844), who sees patients in Mooca, East Zone of São Paulo, explains why decay forms under fillings, the signs, how it is diagnosed and treated, and how to prevent it.

This article comes from Dr. Cleo Salustiano's dental office in Mooca, São Paulo (care in English, Portuguese and Spanish). See the general dentistry page to learn how the treatment is done here and book your assessment. At the clinic, see also: dental fillings in Mooca.

Visiting or living in São Paulo? Dr. Cleo sees patients in English every day, 8 a.m. to 10 p.m. See English-speaking dentist in São Paulo to plan your visit, even before you travel.

Why does decay form under a filling, and what are the signs?

Decay forms when the margin between tooth and filling is no longer sealed because of wear, cracks, ledges, material shrinkage or fracture, and plaque collects there. Signs include a dark margin, sensitivity to sweets or cold, food trapping and sometimes no symptoms at all. Large fillings and poorly adapted contacts between teeth are most prone, and sugar, dry mouth, poor flossing and gum recession increase risk.

A dark line may be decay or just surface stain. Sensitivity in a filled tooth, floss shredding at the same spot, bad taste, a chipped or loose filling and pain on biting deserve an assessment; under metal fillings, decay may be completely hidden.

Diagnosis combines a clinical exam of the margin and adaptation with X-rays, which show dark areas under or beside the filling, especially between teeth. Sometimes the full extent is confirmed only after removing part of the filling.

How is decay under a filling treated, and how can it be prevented?

Treatment removes the filling or the affected part, clears the decay and restores the tooth again. Small, localized margin decay can sometimes be repaired without replacing the whole filling; extensive decay may need a lab-made restoration, a crown or, if it reached the nerve, a root canal. An old filling alone is not a reason to replace it: well-adapted fillings without decay, cracks or symptoms can be kept and monitored, since each replacement removes more tooth.

To prevent it, brush with fluoride toothpaste, floss daily paying attention to filling margins, reduce how often you have sugar and attend checkups that include filling evaluation. People who grind their teeth may need a night guard to protect margins from cracks and wear.

In Mooca, Dr. Cleo Salustiano assesses old fillings with exams and X-rays and provides repairs, replacements and aesthetic fillings, every day from 8 a.m. to 10 p.m., including Sundays and holidays, near Bresser-Mooca subway station, in Portuguese, English and Spanish.

Frequently asked questions: general dentistry

Can there be a cavity under a filling?

+

Yes. When the margin between tooth and filling wears, cracks or forms a ledge, plaque collects and new decay forms, called secondary or recurrent caries. It spreads under the material and is often found only at a checkup with an exam and X-rays.

How do I know if there is decay under my filling?

+

Possible signs are a dark line around the filling, sensitivity to sweets or cold in the filled tooth, food getting stuck, shredding floss, a chipped or loose filling and pain on biting. Often there are no symptoms; an exam with X-rays confirms it.

Does decay under a filling hurt?

+

Usually not at first. Pain appears when it reaches deeper dentin or nears the nerve. Because it is hidden, it can grow considerably before hurting, which is why regular checkups matter for people with fillings.

Is a dark line around my filling a cavity?

+

It may be decay or just surface stain at the junction. Assessment with an instrument, air, light and X-rays helps tell them apart. Stain is solved by polishing or a small repair; decay requires removing the affected area.

Do I need to replace all my old fillings?

+

No. Well-adapted old fillings without decay, cracks or symptoms can be kept and monitored. Each replacement removes a bit more tooth. Replacement is indicated for decay, fracture, leakage, poor adaptation or an aesthetic wish, after an assessment.

Can just the edge of a filling be repaired?

+

Sometimes, yes. When decay or the defect is small and localized at the margin, the dentist can repair only that part without replacing the whole filling, preserving more tooth. It depends on the extent of the problem.

Where can I have old fillings checked in Mooca, São Paulo?

+

In Mooca, Dr. Cleo Salustiano (CRO-SP 170844) sees patients at Rua Hipódromo, 1141, every day from 8 a.m. to 10 p.m., including Sundays and holidays. The evaluation of old fillings includes an exam and X-rays, and replacement is recommended only for a clinical reason or the patient's aesthetic wish.

Read next
Book WhatsApp