Traditional or Self-Ligating Braces: What's the Difference?

Prefer not to wait for a reply? Book online now, no phone call needed: see the open times and pick yours, any time (booking page in Portuguese).

When you research fixed braces, you'll run into two names: traditional and self-ligating. The real difference between them is mechanical and comes down to a single detail — how the wire is held in the bracket. That detail is the source of each system's genuine advantages, and it's also where marketing often goes beyond what science supports.

Here you'll find how each system works, a side-by-side comparison table, what the scientific evidence shows about treatment time, pain and number of appointments, and a step-by-step guide to deciding together with your orthodontist.

This content is for information only and follows the rules of the Federal Council of Dentistry (CFO) and CRO-SP: no promised results and no advertised prices. The right choice always depends on an individual assessment. Dr. Cléo Salustiano (CRO-SP 170844) sees patients at Rua Hipódromo, 1141, in Mooca, São Paulo.

This article comes from Dr. Cléo Salustiano's dental office in Mooca, São Paulo (care in English, Portuguese and Spanish). See the braces and clear aligners page to learn how the treatment is done here and book your assessment.

Step by step

1. Start with the diagnosis, not the bracket. Orthodontic records (X-rays, photos and models or a scan) define which movements your teeth need. Only after that diagnosis does it make sense to discuss which bracket system to use.
2. Ask which system the orthodontist is most experienced with. The orthodontist's experience and technical command of a given system matter more to the result than the brand or type of bracket. Good treatment with traditional brackets beats poorly planned treatment with self-ligating ones.
3. Think about your hygiene routine. If you struggle to keep up with brushing or tend to build up plaque, having no elastic tie with self-ligating braces is a real practical advantage — one less plaque-trapping surface around each bracket.
4. Match your expectations to the evidence. Be wary of promises of treatment that's "much faster," "painless" or "with half the appointments" based only on the type of bracket. Scientific reviews don't support these claims — and the Brazilian Dental Code of Ethics prohibits promising results.
5. Weigh the cost-benefit in your case. Self-ligating braces usually cost more. Ask for a written treatment plan with the planned stages, how often you'll come back and what's included, and compare calmly before deciding.

How each system works: it's all in how the wire is tied

With traditional braces, the orthodontic wire is held to each bracket by a ligature — an elastic ring (the familiar little "rubber bands," which can be colored or clear) or a thin metal tie. This ligature keeps the wire seated and lets it transmit the force that moves the teeth. The elastic ties are replaced at each adjustment appointment.

With self-ligating braces, the bracket has a built-in metal clip or door that closes over the wire. There are no elastic ties. There are two types: passive self-ligating, where the clip simply holds the wire in place loosely — which reduces friction; and active self-ligating, where the clip presses the wire against the base of the slot, giving more control over movement.

That's the structural difference between the two — and it's where the practical advantages of self-ligating braces that actually hold up come from: without the elastic tie, there's less plaque-trapping surface around the bracket, and there's no tie to turn yellow from coffee, tomato sauce or smoking between appointments. The wire also slides with less friction inside the bracket.

What the scientific evidence shows (and what really changes in practice)

You'll often hear that self-ligating braces are "faster," "hurt less" and "need fewer appointments." Systematic reviews comparing the two systems found no statistically significant difference in initial pain, number of appointments or total treatment time. A review with network meta-analysis comparing traditional, passive self-ligating and active self-ligating brackets concluded that the vast majority of variables studied showed no significant difference among the three types.

That doesn't make self-ligating braces a bad choice — it just shows that bracket type isn't what determines treatment success. What really matters is the diagnosis, planning and case management by the orthodontist, together with patient cooperation: wearing elastics when prescribed, thorough hygiene and keeping follow-up appointments.

The advantages of self-ligating braces that hold up are mechanical and hygiene-related: without the elastic tie, there's less plaque buildup around the bracket and nothing to turn yellow between appointments; and lower friction allows lighter forces. On the other hand, traditional braces remain an established option that usually costs less — and colorful ties are often a plus for children and teens. If you're wondering whether the difference in cost pays off, see whether self-ligating braces are worth it in your case.

Whichever system you choose, the care is the same: brush after every meal with an orthodontic toothbrush, floss with a floss threader, watch out for hard and sticky foods (which knock off brackets) and keep your adjustment appointments. If a bracket comes loose or the end of a wire pokes you, contact your orthodontist rather than trying to fix it yourself.

‹

Are Self-Ligating Braces Worth It?

Braces or Clear Aligners: Which Should You Choose?

How much do braces cost? What determines the price

Do Braces Get in the Way of Whitening or Veneers?

›